CARDRUNNERS

What's Your Edge

 
ezmogee's Poker Blog
May 19, 2009
Thoughts?  Source is the book Zero by Charles Seife

Let a and b both be equal to 1.  Since a and b are equal:
 

= ab


Because a equals itself:


a² = a²


Subtract equation 1 from equation 2:


a² - b² = a² - ab


Factor both sides of the equation:


(a + b)(a – b) = a(a – b)


Divide both sides of the equation by (a – b)


a + b = a


Subtract a from both sides and we get:


b = 0


But we set b to 1 at the beginning, so:


1 = 0



May 19, 09 23:56:22

I used to be a math major, but some of the rules are fuzzy to me now. I'm pretty sure there's an error in this proof. When a^2 - b^2 = a^2 - ab, if you fill in 1 you get 0 = 0. Same for the next step. But in the next part you get 2 = 1. So I'm thinking something is flawed in this part?

I also think you can't just subtract one equation from another in step 3. This is not a valid part of the proof, that's my guess.

allreds26





May 20, 09 01:59:50

not true

At the beginning, you assumed that a and b were both equal to 1. You then divided by the quantity (a-b), which is zero. You cannot divide by 0.

It is cool though.

toddletales





May 20, 09 02:19:56

toddle is correct

Zaitsev





May 20, 09 08:26:21

more emo please

jtphila





May 20, 09 12:22:30

divide by 0 = bad.

ManWithBrisk





May 20, 09 13:08:35

Here is proof that girls = Evil:
http://www.stacken.kth.se/lists/best-forestry/2001-05/jpg00000.jpg

Prove me wrong.

Subtracting equation 1 from equation 2 is where you start to go wrong I think. Why subtract at all, lets add, multiply, divide, you are creating the rules as you go aren't you!

SixPeppers





May 20, 09 15:21:48

"Factor both sides of the equation:


(a + b)(a – b) = a(a – b)
"

This made me insta-WAT?

busta





May 20, 09 18:41:28

[url]http://shhac.info/x/b/divide_by_zero.jpg[/url]

[url]http://halshop.files.wordpress.com/2008/04/dividedbyzero2.jpg[/url]

Hokulea





May 21, 09 06:00:42

solution

can't divide by (a-b) cuz a-b = 0
this was a math question i got for homework at harvard summer school

choooo





May 21, 09 10:56:53

You can subtract equation 1 from equation 2 because both sides of e1 are equal and so you are essentially subtracting the same thing from both sides of equation 2.

http://www.angelzfunnyz.com/Portals/0/Gallery/Album/8/DivideByZero.jpg

ManWithBrisk





May 21, 09 13:08:22

makes sense, thanks guys

ezmogee





May 21, 09 13:08:28

makes sense, thanks guys

ezmogee





May 22, 09 05:23:15

Yep, cant devide by 0 as said by others. Therrs ya problem!

SubZero616





597 Views | Comments (13)

CardRunners
CardRunners